Matters of the Heart
Imam Ghazali’s “Marvels of the Heart”
American Islamic College
Chicago, Illinois
April 3, 2014
Dr. Umar Faruq Abdullah
– today’s topic is lying
– sometimes have to do ijtihad and look at a situation and this is a high trust
– ultimate goal of speech is not to lie, ultimate goal is to use it to access the truth, learn the truth through honest speech, to live the truth and give it to others
– not the purpose of speech to lie or say things that are contrary to what we mean, but sometimes you have to do that and will discuss some of the situations
– for instance in a situation where you are taken as prisoner by an authoritarian government and if you tell the truth you are in danger you must lie in this situation
– we have to protect ourselves and others, we have to cultivate good relations between ourselves and others, especially in our families and especially between spouses and we have to protect the ties that are there and sometimes that even justifies and even requires exceptions to the rule
– but must never lose sight of fact that purpose of speech is to be a vehicle of truth, we must never make the exception the rule
– as humans we are speech creatures, our tongues and speech are the great mediator between ourselves and all forms of truth, it’s the means of access we have to God and knowledge and wisdom and supreme gift of intellect and ability to understand revelation
– when use articulate speech properly then it makes us like the Angels, each of us is clay and spirit and speech is that which enables spirit to dominate, and angels are pure intellect, pure truthfulness and they relate only the truth and that’s the way we’re supposed to be
– honest speech, thinking about what we say, speaking carefully when we speak these are things that make us best human beings
– proper use of articulation in speech and writing, very important today when we live in a time when people use words any way they want, a time of linguistic chaos, we must pay attention to language carefully so that we know what each other means when we communicate
– in history of islam were very careful about language and very careful to define our words, society we’re in today we often use words as powerful instruments of suggestion but we don’t really know what we’re saying or what we mean
o for instance we use the word modernity, which has a lot of meaning for people today, but what is modernity? It’s not just living in this time, so we have to know about that
o another example, we use words like nature, what does this mean?
– We need to use articulate speech which is what frees the intellect and enables us to live as a civilization
– Proper use of writing and speech is what sets us apart from other living things God has created except for angels and jinn
– Truthfulness is the key that opens thte door so that we can fulfill the adamic mission that we have, that you are special and unlike anything else as we are the son/daughter of Adam, if you get yourself right the world gets right
– It’s the state of the hearts and reality of the tongues of the billions of people who don’t believe in God that destroy the cosmos
– Tonight will talk about the exception, we emphasize this introduction to make clear that we sometimes have to lie, we sometimes have to use puns or word play or misleading speech but that has to be an exception and not a custom or a habit
– Imam Ghazali tells us about that today, will show us even when we use our language in such a way that it is a departure from explicit truthfulness, that departure itself must be an act of truthfulness
o In order to be true to self and others, I’ve got to do or say something else
– Begin by talking about lying, Imam Ghazali makes it clear lying is forbidden/haram/hateful to God—that’s the basic rule and foundation, but lying is haram not in and of itself but because of the harm that it produces, what it leads to, it’s not an absolute prohibition like polytheism would be for instance
– Lying is forbidden because as a rule it brings tremendous harm and distorts reality, it hurts people and destroys relationships, it infects good character
– But there are times when lying is obligatory
– As mentioned before, you’re not allowed to tell a murderer where he can find his victim for instance
– If you know a person wants to rob you you don’t tell them how much money you have or where it is for ex
– If you’re taken in by secret police in an oppressive country you don’t tell them things that will lead to harm
– It is obligatory in islam to protect innocent life, it’s obligatory in islam to protect good relationships between ourselves and cultivate them
o So if honesty would lead to loss of innocent life then honesty is not permissible
o If to speak the truth would destroy relationships, it’s sinful to be honest if it would do that because we have to cultivate a sound relationship and sometimes if we say everything on our mind or that we feel it can destroy a relationship
o You can’t disclose vital secrets to the enemy, that’s regarded as an act of treason. Prophet Muhammad (SAW) permitted lying in war, one of greatest things we see about the Prophet Muhammad (SAW) are the amazing strategies he used which often involved lying
- For ex when Medina was surrounded by the confederates the biggest assembly ever seen bent on extermination of muslims, a man comes to the Prophet Muhammad (SAW) a Bedouin and says I can help you but will you let me lie and he lets him lie and he goes to Quraysh and tells them a lie about their allies in Medina and does the same to the allies in Medina telling them a lie about Quraysh and manages to break the confederation this way
- In battle of Uhud, which was an outward defeat for muslims, the Prophet Muhammad (SAW) immediately chases quraysh after that battle and only lets the people in the battle of Uhud come and then Quraysh goes to a great valley and has his men light bonfires around rim of valley. Man goes to head of quraysh and tells him the Prophet Muhammad (SAW) has come to get you and is very angry with you and he looks up and sees bonfires, only one person behind each but assumed there were hundreds so they leave in fear, this was a strategy to save lives
– Imam Al Ghazali says even when lying is permissible we must avoid it as much as possible, for whoever opens the door to lying it is greatly to be feared that they will become accustomed to it and use it when it is not required or not even allowed
– Um Qulthum, Uthman’s maternal sister, said I did not hear god’s messenger give permission to lie about anything except in 3 situations:
o a man says something by which he intends to set things right between others(you know two people are always fighting so you say he likes you and says good things about you to those two people—that’s permissible to do)
o a man says something in war
- for example says we’re only 100 people when you’re 10,009
o when a man speaks to his wife or woman speaks to her husband, and you can say all sorts of beautiful things
- may say things that are not exactly true, we want to love our spouses but sometimes that means you have to exaggerate
- for ex don’t tell your husband or wife you don’t love them even if it’s true, for husband and wife to grow together over time you will be tested and you may not always see that same love in the other person but you must try to get back to where you were and try to make it better which requires all sorts of strategies and avoiding hateful words even if they’re true
- a lot of people believe I have to tell my spouse everything, you don’t tell absolutely everything, if you’ve done things wrong you don’t tell those things
- there was a man in Medina in the days of Omar which had a big problem with his wives he gets married and divorced married and divorced. He went to his wife and said do you swear to me by Allah that you love me and she says don’t do that and she says no. he goes to omar and brings the wife and he says why did you do this and she said he made me swear by god I can’t lie and Omar said, you have to lie in a situation like this. She said then should I lie and omar replied to her yes but if one of you oh you women out there does not love her husband as one of us the community of men, let her not speak about it. And then he said for it is the rarest of houses that is built on love, rather people live together in marriage in a nice way on the basis of islam doing what you’re supposed to do and character, dignity.
- And love is extremely important in marriage but marriage has to be a basic dignity and goodness, purpose of marriage is good company, if you do the marriage right then love grows after marriage so it’s not necessarily the foundation of marriage
– The companion Thawban said all forms of lying are wrongful except what brings necessary benefit to another person or wards of from that other person harm
– You are not permitted to tell the abominable, obscene things that happen to us. If a person for ex commits adultery you don’t tell people that you did that. If you’ve committed theft for ex you don’t tell people we did that, we’re not allowed to tell people we did that
o For ex. If someone was in jail you’re not to ask them what they did that put them in jail, that’s not our business
o Telling that obscene thing that you did is sometimes a greater obscenity than the obscene thing you did itself
– Imam Ghazali says when you lie, you can only lie to avoid the madhur (that which must be avoided) and there are situations when telling the truth produces something which must be avoided
o Must figure out which is worst, problem that comes from telling the truth or benefit that comes from not telling that
o You must weigh that in the scales of justice and you must do ijtihad
– We often want things in black and white clear, but we have to make judgment and decisions, especially when you speak train yourself to speak in your heart before you do on your tongue
o This may be difficult because it’s not our habit
o Often when we speak we may be thinking out loud
o Must learn to talk in your heart without moving your tongue
o And before you speak in public, try to say it first in your heart
– Abu Bakr used to put a pebble on his tongue so he couldn’t speak until he took the pebble off of his tongue so he would think carefully before he spoke
– It is only permissible to lie when there is absolute necessity or if there is some great need, if it is less than that then it’s better to speak the truth, but you must exercise your judgment, and avoid lying as much as you can
– Imam Ghazali says but most people lie for personal gain, for hudhur (personal benefit), they lie for ex to get money, fame, friends, and all of this is to be avoided it’s reprehensible. Sometimes they lie to hurt other people or destroy relationships that’s absolutely prohibited
– What is the greatest lie of all? To lie against Allah and his Messenger, that’s the greatest lie of all. To fabricate things and to say the Prophet Muhammad (SAW) said them when he didn’t say them. We have to be careful when we speak about the Prophet Muhammad (SAW) and have to know what we’re saying
o Prophet Muhammad (SAW) said whoever lies about me let him or her take his seat in the fire
- That’s most authentic hadith of all the hadiths and the most frequently transmitted of all hadith
– We may talk about hadith, but you had better know what you’re saying if you’re going to say you can or can’t do this and this is halal or haram. You’re talking about Allah you had better get it right
o You don’t say this is halal or haram unless you know what you’re talking about
o Very important to say I don’t know the answer to that question
o To tell lies about the Prophet Muhammad (SAW) could be a mistake
– To say something is haram when it’s not haram or a matter of consensus or to say it’s obligatory when it’s not is a greater sin than adultery or fornication and other kabayr that’s because to lie about the Prophet Muhammad (SAW) and the religion is one of the greatest sins of all
– One of greatest sins of all is to lie about your dreams. If you see a dream don’t tell it to everybody, you can tell it to some people. If the dream is from God it’s from revelation you’ve got to tell it right can’t add to it or take away from it or make it a little better than it was. Never lie about the Prophet Muhammad (SAW).
o If you didn’t see the Prophet Muhammad (SAW) don’t make up a dream about him that’s a major sin
– Prophet Muhammad (SAW) said another thing you don’t lie about are qaramat (miraculous things that happen to God’s saints). Sahaba had many of those. We believe in qaramat, but in Muslim world have people who lie about that and make them up, that’s a huge sin because qaramat are also a part of prophecy because when a saint, a friend of Allah, is given a qarama that shows they are following the Prophet Muhammad (SAW) and are inheriting from him part of his prophecy so must be careful of it.
– Prophet Muhammad (SAW) said the lie of lies, the most ugly of lies, is that a man be called to be the son of someone other than his father. Should be proud of your parents and don’t ever change that.
o Never call a person by anything that isn’t valid regarding their parentage
– It’s also very important to not say things that we don’t really know
– Also you shouldn’t show your eye what it didn’t see in a dream. So if have a dream and it’s clear get up and write it down, but be very careful not to add. Dreams are a treasure, get them right
– Next topic: when we don’t lie, but we make a play on words, and we say things that mean two things or more and I mean one thing, but I want you to understand something else (called tarir in Arabic) in English we have puns which is an example of tarir
o this is something you can do to avoid lying, if you have to lie if you can say something true that gives a different meaning then that’s a good thing to do
o this is also something of great intelligence and often humorous
o sometimes have to have a play on words to avoid harm and danger, and sometimes play on words is an incredibly courageous act
– Prophet Muhammad (SAW) when he went to Medina with Abu Bakr rode behind Abu Bakr and said to Abu Bakr turn the people away from me because it’s not proper that a prophet lie, so he’s saying they’re in enemy territory and if they ask who are you to Abu Bakr and Abu Bakr would say I’m a person who’s urgently looking for something he needs (it’s not a lie he’s looking for guidance) and when ask who is behind you says he’s a guide (which is true the Prophet was the guide for humanity)
– Often the upright of the ummah say these things that are a play on words to get them out of difficult situations
– There are types of wordplay you have to be careful of, for example Abdullah ibn Utbah a great early muslim who went to visit the caliph and puts on the most beautiful clothing he has when he visits. He goes with his father and when he comes out the people see this is a garment the prince of the believers put on you isn’t it, and so he said may Allah reward the prince of the believers with good (that’s not a lie). But his father turned to him beware of lying or saying anything like that, he said that because his son wanted the people to believe the caliph did give him the garment and thus he has such great status which is not true so we must be careful to not do that
– If you only said something one time, don’t say I’ve told you a hundred times, but if you’ve said it multiple times then you can say that because it’s not really the number but that you’ve told it several times
– In conclusion, remember the purpose of speech, foundation of speech is to keep silent or to say something good. And speech and silence go together like gold and silver, and silence is gold and silence can be greatest honesty and truthfulness of all
– We’re not about finding situations in which we can lie, basic principle is to speak the truth which opens the gates of all good to us
– But you cannot cause harm to people
– There are times when lying is allowed, times when it’s required, but they must be justified and they must also be acts of truthfulness
Filed under: halaqa, Imam Ghazali's "Marvels of the Heart", Iman High, Lying: Limitations & Necessity | Leave a comment »